Alert to all Active-Duty Service Members:  Failed Anthrax Vaccine Immunization Program to again become mandatory

Here is an update:

 

On Monday, October 16, from 2:30 to 3:30 p.m. EST Dr. William Winkenwerder, the Dod's Assistant Secretary of Defense for Health Affairs, will discuss the department's resumption of the mandatory Anthrax Vaccine Immunization Program (AVIP).  Concerned citizens and members of the media who would like to ask questions should call: 1 866 866-2244.  The pass code is 9120436.

 

It perplexes The Military Vaccine Resource Directory and other grassroots groups of concerned citizens and professionals that The Dod would make such a move in light of the yet unresolved questions about the safety, efficacy and legality of the current anthrax vaccine. 

 

It is important that facts uncovered over the past eight years continue to be held up to the light as members of the media and Congressional staffers assess the DoD's re-launch of this previously failed program.  Private citizens, members of Congress, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) and the Federal Courts have all detailed a deceitful and discouraging history regarding the development and use of the anthrax vaccine.  Key findings and reports are listed below.

 

·        The anthrax vaccine program was illegal from its inception. Congressional House Report 106-556 -- The Department of Defense Anthrax Vaccine Immunization Program (TEXTPDF).  This lone report by the US Congress determined that the program was implemented in 1998 in conflict with FDA regulations, and therefore was illegal under US law.  The Government Accountability Office similarly investigated the anthrax vaccine's use by the DoD, publishing exclusively critical reports.  A simple search of the GAO website reveals the program's history in no less than 20 reports and testimonies. 

·        The problems with the anthrax vaccine program have not been fixed, nor have long-standing concerns been addressed.  The GAO 2006 assessment of the anthrax vaccine doesn't yield to compromise.  Those findings continued to question the "long-term and short-term safety of the vaccine, including gender differences; and the vaccine’s efficacy."  While confirming that the "long-term safety of the licensed vaccine has not been studied," the GAO also confirms the efficacy of the vaccine for the DoD's intended use against inhaled anthrax "may not be extrapolated to humans."  So when Dr Winkenwerder says the vaccine is now finally approved by the FDA for use against inhalation anthrax this is only true on FDA's letterhead, and is not supported by scientific fact.  In addition, it has long been known that many of the experts on this issue have been paid by the DoD for their testimony; this was particularly true of the 2002 Institute of Medicine Report, which was paid for entirely by the DoD and did not contain any dissenting testimony, including previous concerns expressed by the Army itself.  

·        Recent court decisions do NOT confirm that the program was legal.

 Though the DoD's internal military judges at the Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces ruled that the DoD presumed the order to be legal previously, and therefore refused to reverse previous court-martials, the US Federal Court system has ruled the program was illegal, first with a preliminary injunction, followed by a permanent injunction on summary judgment. 

 

It is notable that the military court ignored and denied the submission of any evidence in all previous court-martials for those later imprisoned for refusing the anthrax vaccine, whereas the federal courts analyzed the complete administrative record concerning the vaccine's history.  Similarly the military court ruling misinterprets or misrepresents the content and context of the previous federal court rulings,  omitting the fact that the program was declared to have been illegal.

 

A great deal of research about the failures of the DoD's program has been collected over the past eight years.  Unfortunately a whole new generation of young troops and new commanders are now being asked to carry the untenable burden of the mandatory anthrax vaccine program's implementation.  To quote the Dod itself, education is, indeed, the key.  It is imperative that you become educated about the anthrax vaccine program and it’s history.  You may be told that everything is fine now – it’s not. 

 

Dr. Winkenwerder tried to convey such a message in December of 2003 on national TV when he said the federal judge was "absolutely" wrong in his ruling -- only to have the anthrax vaccine program shut down by a subsequent injunction in October of 2004.  It was Dr. Winkenwerder himself who was wrong, a fact confirmed by the Federal Appeals Court in February of 2006 when it declined to vacate or overrule the injunction.

 

Clearly our country has been down this road too often.  On this web site, under the link titled “History of Human Experimentation,” you’ll read more about the medical experimentation conducted upon out troops since WW II.  Does Congress know?  Yes.  In a 1994 document known as the Rockerfeller report, Congress strongly criticized the Pentagon for such experiments – then did nothing. From radiation testing to Agent Orange to Gulf War Illness, the Dod has followed a predictable problem:  it first denies there is a problem, then delays accountability, and disparages (and, in the case of active-duty troops, punishes) those who question and criticize the DoD studies and policies.  Service members who question or refuse these policies can loose their careers – and, too often, their health.

 

America's private citizens, the media, Congress and Courts are not subjected to such injustice.  At least not yet. 

Become educated; think for yourself; and always think twice.

 

Sincerely,

 

Kathy Hubbell, Director MVRD

 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Text of DoD announcement invite as posted on anthrax-no by Dr Nass:

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Dear Medical Reporter:

This is to invite you to a telephone media roundtable with Dr. William Winkenwerder, Jr., Assistant Secretary of Defense for Health  Affairs, on Monday, October 16, from 2:30 to 3:30 p.m. est.  At that time, Dr. Winkenwerder will discuss the department's resumption of  the mandatory Anthrax Vaccine Immunization Program (AVIP) for  military personnel, emergency-essential DoD civilians and  contractors, based on geographic areas or roles.  DoD anthrax  immunizations will be administered consistent with the FDA-licensed  dose schedule and current standards for medical practice.

Terry D. Jones, APR
Office of Communications
Assistant Secretary of Defense (Health Affairs)
5111 Leesburg Pike
Skyline 5, Suite 601
Falls Church, VA  22041
(703) 681-1698
Fax: (703) 681-3656
DoD Health Affairs Web site: http://www.ha.osd.mil